| 171* | GM Turner | v East Africa at Birmingham, World Cup, 1975 [20] |
| 141 | SB Styris | v Sri Lanka at Bloemfontein, World Cup, 2002/03 [1944] |
| 134* | SP Fleming | v South Africa at Johannesburg, World Cup, 2002/03 [1955] |
| 130 | CZ Harris | v Australia at Madras, World Cup, 1995/96 [1080] |
| 114* | GM Turner | v India at Manchester, World Cup, 1975 [28] |
| 111* | SB Styris | v Sri Lanka at St George's, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2569] |
| 102* | SP Fleming | v Bangladesh at North Sound, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2561] |
| 102* | NJ Astle | v Zimbabwe at Bloemfontein, World Cup, 2002/03 [1984] |
| 101 | L Vincent | v Canada at Gros Islet, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2548] |
| 101 | NJ Astle | v England at Ahmedabad, World Cup, 1995/96 [1048] |
| 100* | MD Crowe | v Australia at Auckland, World Cup, 1991/92 [714] |
| 97 | MD Crowe | v England at The Oval, World Cup, 1983 [197] |
| 92 | RG Twose | v United Arab Emirates at Faisalabad, World Cup, 1995/96 [1064] |
| 91 | MD Crowe | v Pakistan at Auckland, World Cup, 1991/92 [750] |
| 89 | LK Germon | v Australia at Madras, World Cup, 1995/96 [1080] |
| 88* | JJ Crowe | v Zimbabwe at Calcutta, World Cup, 1987/88 [466] |
| 87* | SB Styris | v England at Gros Islet, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2536] |
| 85 | RL Taylor | v Kenya at Gros Islet, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2544] |
| 84* | BA Edgar | v India at Leeds, World Cup, 1979 [65] |
| 83* | GM Turner | v Sri Lanka at Nottingham, World Cup, 1979 [62] |
| 83 | PG Fulton | v Ireland at Providence, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2566] |
| 81* | MD Crowe | v West Indies at Auckland, World Cup, 1991/92 [734] |
| 80* | SB Styris | v West Indies at North Sound, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2557] |
| 80* | RG Twose | v Australia at Cardiff, World Cup, 1999 [1452] |
| 78 | CM Spearman | v United Arab Emirates at Faisalabad, World Cup, 1995/96 [1064] |
| 78 | AH Jones | v England at Wellington, World Cup, 1991/92 [744] |
| 76 | GP Howarth | v Sri Lanka at Bristol, World Cup, 1983 [206] |
| 75 | CD McMillan | v Bangladesh at Kimberley, World Cup, 2002/03 [1968] |
| 75 | KR Rutherford | v India at Bangalore, World Cup, 1987/88 [458] |
| 74* | MD Crowe | v Zimbabwe at Napier, World Cup, 1991/92 [728] |
| 74 | MJ Horne | v India at Nottingham, World Cup, 1999 [1480] |
| 73* | MD Crowe | v England at Wellington, World Cup, 1991/92 [744] |
| 73 | MJ Greatbatch | v India at Dunedin, World Cup, 1991/92 [740] |
| 72 | MD Crowe | v Zimbabwe at Hyderabad (Deccan), World Cup, 1987/88 [454] |
| 71 | CD McMillan | v Kenya at Gros Islet, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2544] |
| 69 | SP Fleming | v Pakistan at Derby, World Cup, 1999 [1466] |
| 69 | JG Wright | v England at Manchester, World Cup, 1979 [72] |
| 68 | CM Spearman | v Netherlands at Baroda, World Cup, 1995/96 [1051] |
| 68 | MJ Greatbatch | v South Africa at Auckland, World Cup, 1991/92 [723] |
| 67* | AH Jones | v India at Dunedin, World Cup, 1991/92 [740] |
| 66* | JV Coney | v England at Birmingham, World Cup, 1983 [209] |
| 66 | SP Fleming | v Canada at Gros Islet, ICC World Cup, 2006/07 [2548] |
| 66 | SP Fleming | v Netherlands at Baroda, World Cup, 1995/96 [1051] |
| 66 | JM Parker | v East Africa at Birmingham, World Cup, 1975 [20] |
| 65* | KR Rutherford | v Sri Lanka at Hamilton, World Cup, 1991/92 [718] |
| 64 | AH Jones | v India at Bangalore, World Cup, 1987/88 [458] |
| 64 | MC Snedden | v Zimbabwe at Hyderabad (Deccan), World Cup, 1987/88 [454] |
