From Palwankar to Nayudu
No country has thrown up a more mesmeric variety of spin bowlers than India
Partab Ramchand
06-Oct-2001
No country has thrown up a more mesmeric variety of spin bowlers than
India. And it has not been just the variety that has fascinated
cricket connoisseurs the world over, but how the bowlers have managed
to be among the greatest in contemporary cricket. Vinoo Mankad in his
time was the finest left arm spin bowler in the world, Subash Gupte
the best of his type, while the spin quartet, of course, re-wrote the
history of spin bowling.
The best batsmen the world over have always admitted that their cricketing education has not been complete without successfully tackling the Indian spin bowlers, particularly on their home wickets. In their own way, they have bewildered batsmen as much as the most fearsome fast bowlers have terrorized them. |
The best batsmen the world over have always admitted that their cricketing
education has not been complete without successfully tackling the
Indian spin bowlers, particularly on their home wickets. In their own
way, they have bewildered batsmen as much as the most fearsome fast
bowlers have terrorized them.
The tradition of the best of Indian spin bowling can be traced back
almost 100 years and to Baloo Palwankar. Today he is acknowledged as
the first great Indian spinner. He had to come up the hard way,
fighting the caste considerations of those days.
Born in Bombay in 1876, Palwankar was an `untouchable' (Gandhiji later
called them Harijans) and worked as a groundsman at a club for a
paltry salary of three rupees a month. His low caste status meant
that, despite being a gifted bowler, he could not play for the Hindu
Gymkhana, a prestigious Bombay club at the time. The Parsees, who had
played a notable role in popularizing the game in the country in the
late 19th century and early 20th century, gave him the opportunity to
play. Subsequently, when the Hindus discovered that there was a
certain magic in his fingers, he was quickly made a member of the club
and later went on to captain the Hindus!
Prof DB Deodhar was of the view that Palwankar was as good a bowler as
Wilfred Rhodes and Hedley Verity. On the all-India tour of England in
1911, the gifted left-arm spinner took over 114 wickets at the
niggardly average of 18.86.
He played first class cricket for the Hindus in the Quadrangular till
1921 and his overall figures serve to show what a good bowler he
undoubtedly was. During his career, which started in 1905, he took 179
wickets at 15.21 apiece. He died in Bombay in 1955 and now has a road
named after him in the metropolis.
As Indian cricket came of age in the 20s and 30s, the focus shifted to
pace in the form of Mohammad Nissar and Ladha Amar Singh. With the
medium-paced cutters of CK Nayudu and Jahangir Khan for support, there
was very little scope for spin to succeed.
The one spinner who could just about get a place in the Indian side at
this time was Rusi Jamshedji. He was born in Bombay in 1892 but made
his first-class debut only at the age of 30. A left-arm spinner of the
orthodox school, he played with some success in the two unofficial
Tests against Arthur Gilligan's MCC team of 1926-27, but he made his
Test debut only against Douglas Jardine's team seven years later.
By this time he was 41 and still remains the oldest Indian player to
make his debut. He did well enough though, picking up three wickets
for 137 from 35 overs. That remained his only Test and under the
shadow of the well-established and immensely successful pace duo of
Nissar and Amar Singh, there was never any chance for a spin bowler to
be a force to reckon with an interesting fact given the acute
scarcity of pace bowlers in later years.
Given this scenario, it is not surprising that Mushtaq Ali was picked
for his first couple of Tests primarily as a left-arm spin bowler. But
India's best bet around this time was probably Cottari Subbana Nayudu,
the younger brother of CK. Born in 1914 at Nagpur, Nayudu was a right
arm leg-spin-cum-googly bowler who spun the ball fiercely.
A bundle of energy, he made his firstclass debut in 1931, his Test
debut in England in 1936, and between 1934 and 1961 in the Ranji
Trophy had a bag of 295 wickets a record until VV Kumar broke it in
1970-71.
He was a prominent member of the formidable Holkar side of the 40s and
50s and took 14 wickets in a match once, besides twice exceeding 30
wickets in a season, which, given the limited opportunities in those
days, was a commendable feat. He was also a batsman capable of getting
four first class hundreds. But somehow his career for India proved
disappointing, as illustrated by his figures in 11 Tests two wickets
at 179.50 apiece.
Nayudu still holds the record of bowling more overs in a match than
anyone else. In the 1944-45 Ranji Trophy final against Bombay, he sent
down 152.5 overs 917 deliveries in all to bag 11 wickets. By the
time Nayudu had played his last Test against England in 1951-52, India
were on the verge of discovering their first outstanding spin trio.