| 152* | CH Gayle | West Indies v South Africa at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 139 | JH Kallis | South Africa v West Indies at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 109* | JH Kallis | South Africa v West Indies at Cape Town, 1st ODI, 25/01/2004 [2088] |
| 95* | JH Kallis | South Africa v West Indies at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 92 | S Chanderpaul | West Indies v South Africa at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 85 | S Chanderpaul | West Indies v South Africa at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 83 | HH Dippenaar | South Africa v West Indies at Port Elizabeth, 2nd ODI, 28/01/2004 [2090] |
| 77* | RR Sarwan | West Indies v South Africa at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 61* | JA Rudolph | South Africa v West Indies at Cape Town, 1st ODI, 25/01/2004 [2088] |
| 59* | BC Lara | West Indies v South Africa at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 58 | GC Smith | South Africa v West Indies at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 53 | GC Smith | South Africa v West Indies at Cape Town, 1st ODI, 25/01/2004 [2088] |
| 50 | RL Powell | West Indies v South Africa at Durban, 3rd ODI, 30/01/2004 [2092] |
| 49* | RL Powell | West Indies v South Africa at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 46 | GC Smith | South Africa v West Indies at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 41* | L Klusener | South Africa v West Indies at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 36 | RJ Peterson | South Africa v West Indies at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 35 | JA Rudolph | South Africa v West Indies at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 34 | RL Powell | West Indies v South Africa at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 30 | HH Dippenaar | South Africa v West Indies at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 29 | RR Sarwan | West Indies v South Africa at Durban, 3rd ODI, 30/01/2004 [2092] |
| 28 | HH Dippenaar | South Africa v West Indies at Johannesburg, 5th ODI, 04/02/2004 [2096] |
| 26 | SM Pollock | South Africa v West Indies at Port Elizabeth, 2nd ODI, 28/01/2004 [2090] |
| 26 | CH Gayle | West Indies v South Africa at Centurion, 4th ODI, 01/02/2004 [2094] |
| 24 | DR Smith | West Indies v South Africa at Port Elizabeth, 2nd ODI, 28/01/2004 [2090] |
| 24 | R Rampaul | West Indies v South Africa at Port Elizabeth, 2nd ODI, 28/01/2004 [2090] |
| 21 | RJ Peterson | South Africa v West Indies at Cape Town, 1st ODI, 25/01/2004 [2088] |
